Keyword Guide · study-guide-general

Marilla’s Feelings Towards Anne: Chapter 2 Study Guide

This guide breaks down Marilla Cuthbert’s evolving attitude toward Anne Shirley in Chapter 2 of Anne of Green Gables. It’s built for class discussion, quiz review, and essay drafting. Start with the quick answer to grasp core points fast.

In Chapter 2, Marilla starts as rigid and frustrated by Anne’s unexpected arrival and nonstop talking. She softens slightly when she sees Anne’s vulnerability and earnestness, though she still clings to her plan to send Anne back. Jot these two core shifts in your notes right now.

Next Step

Speed Up Your Study Time

Get instant, text-aligned analysis of Marilla’s feelings and other key literary topics with Readi.AI. It’s designed for high school and college literature students.

  • AI-powered text analysis tailored to your reading
  • Instant thesis statements and discussion questions
  • Personalized study plans for quizzes and essays
Visual of a student's study workflow: a notebook with a two-column chart tracking Marilla's feelings in Anne of Green Gables Chapter 2, paired with the book and sticky note reminders

Answer Block

Marilla’s feelings in Chapter 2 are defined by initial irritation and guardedness, paired with a quiet, unacknowledged empathy that emerges as she interacts with Anne. She is bound by her sense of duty to her brother Matthew and her strict, routine-driven lifestyle. Her internal conflict creates the chapter’s emotional core.

Next step: List three specific moments from the chapter that show Marilla’s irritation, then three that show her softening.

Key Takeaways

  • Marilla’s initial frustration stems from Anne disrupting her orderly life and original adoption plan
  • Her small acts of kindness reveal a hidden capacity for empathy she hasn’t fully embraced
  • Marilla’s feelings are tied to her fear of change and her loyalty to Matthew’s wishes
  • This chapter establishes the foundation for their future mother-daughter bond

20-Minute Plan and 60-Minute Plan

20-minute plan

  • Read the quick answer and key takeaways, then add 2 personal observations from your own reading
  • Draft 2 discussion questions using the sentence starters from the essay kit
  • Write a 1-sentence thesis statement about Marilla’s core motivation in the chapter

60-minute plan

  • Re-read Chapter 2, marking 5 moments that show Marilla’s shifting feelings
  • Complete the how-to block’s exercise to map her emotional arc
  • Draft a full essay outline using one of the skeleton templates
  • Quiz yourself using the exam kit’s self-test questions

3-Step Study Plan

1

Action: Map Marilla’s emotional beats

Output: A 2-column chart: one column for Marilla’s actions, one for her likely underlying feelings

2

Action: Connect her feelings to broader themes

Output: A 3-bullet list linking her behavior to themes of duty, change, and empathy

3

Action: Practice applying insights to prompts

Output: A 5-sentence response to a sample essay prompt about Marilla’s character

Discussion Kit

  • What specific behavior of Anne’s first frustrates Marilla, and why does it bother her so much?
  • How does Marilla’s interaction with Anne differ from Matthew’s, and what does that reveal about her?
  • Is Marilla’s softening in Chapter 2 a choice, or a reaction to Anne’s vulnerability? Defend your answer.
  • How does Marilla’s strict adherence to routine shape her feelings towards Anne?
  • What might Marilla’s unspoken thoughts reveal about her own unmet needs?
  • If Marilla had been alone when Anne arrived, would she have sent her away immediately? Explain.
  • How does this chapter set up Marilla’s character development later in the book?

Essay Kit

Thesis Templates

  • In Chapter 2 of Anne of Green Gables, Marilla’s shifting feelings towards Anne reveal a quiet battle between her commitment to order and her repressed capacity for compassion.
  • Marilla’s initial irritation and eventual softening towards Anne in Chapter 2 highlight the impact of unexpected change on a rigid, duty-bound character.

Outline Skeletons

  • 1. Intro with thesis; 2. Evidence of Marilla’s initial frustration; 3. Evidence of her softening; 4. Link to broader themes; 5. Conclusion
  • 1. Intro with thesis; 2. Marilla’s core motivation (duty to Matthew); 3. Anne’s impact on Marilla’s routine; 4. Unacknowledged empathy; 5. Conclusion

Sentence Starters

  • Marilla’s reaction to Anne’s [specific action] shows that she…
  • One small moment that reveals Marilla’s hidden softness is when she…

Essay Builder

Ace Your Next Literary Essay

Readi.AI can help you turn your notes into a polished essay draft in minutes. It supports thesis writing, outline building, and evidence citation for all major literary works.

  • Generate custom essay outlines for any prompt
  • Get feedback on your thesis statements
  • Find text evidence to support your claims

Exam Kit

Checklist

  • I can list 3 specific moments showing Marilla’s frustration
  • I can list 3 specific moments showing Marilla’s softening
  • I can explain how Marilla’s feelings tie to her character traits
  • I can link Marilla’s emotions to the book’s core themes
  • I can draft a clear thesis statement about this chapter
  • I can answer discussion questions with text evidence
  • I can identify the difference between Marilla’s words and her unspoken feelings
  • I can connect this chapter to Marilla’s later character development
  • I can avoid making unsupported claims about Marilla’s motives
  • I can use concrete examples alongside vague statements

Common Mistakes

  • Claiming Marilla loves Anne already in Chapter 2 (her softening is subtle, not full affection)
  • Focusing only on Marilla’s frustration without acknowledging her empathy
  • Using vague statements alongside specific, text-based moments
  • Ignoring Marilla’s loyalty to Matthew as a key motivation
  • Treating Marilla as a one-dimensional 'mean' character

Self-Test

  • Name two specific actions Marilla takes that show her softening towards Anne in Chapter 2.
  • What is the main source of Marilla’s initial frustration with Anne?
  • How does Marilla’s personality contrast with Matthew’s in this chapter?

How-To Block

1

Action: Re-read Chapter 2 and mark every time Marilla’s tone or behavior changes

Output: A list of 4-6 key moments tagged as 'frustrated' or 'softened'

2

Action: For each marked moment, write 1 sentence explaining how it reveals Marilla’s underlying feelings

Output: A linked set of evidence and analysis notes

3

Action: Arrange the moments in chronological order to map her emotional arc

Output: A linear timeline showing Marilla’s shift from irritation to guarded empathy

Rubric Block

Text Evidence

Teacher looks for: Specific, cited moments from Chapter 2 that support claims about Marilla’s feelings

How to meet it: Avoid vague phrases like 'Marilla was mean'; instead, reference her specific actions or tone in a key scene

Analysis Depth

Teacher looks for: Explanations of why Marilla feels a certain way, not just what she does

How to meet it: Link her feelings to her established character traits, like her love of routine or loyalty to Matthew

Theme Connection

Teacher looks for: Links between Marilla’s feelings and the book’s broader themes

How to meet it: Explain how her emotional shift ties to ideas like change, empathy, or chosen family

Marilla’s Initial Frustration

Marilla’s first reaction to Anne is rooted in disruption. Her life is built on strict routine, and Anne’s unexpected arrival shatters her carefully laid plans. She is also annoyed by Anne’s constant talking and vivid imagination, which feel unruly and unnecessary to her. Write down one specific way Anne disrupts Marilla’s routine in your notes.

Marilla’s Hidden Softening

As the chapter progresses, Marilla shows small signs of care for Anne. These moments are quiet and easily missed, but they reveal a side of her she rarely shows. She acts out of a sense of basic decency, even as she insists she will send Anne away. Use this before class to contribute a nuanced observation about Marilla’s character.

Conflict Between Duty and Empathy

Marilla’s core conflict in Chapter 2 is between her duty to Matthew and her growing empathy for Anne. She promised to support Matthew’s adoption plan, but Anne is not the boy they expected. She struggles to reconcile her sense of obligation with her unexpected feelings of care. Draft a 1-sentence explanation of this conflict for your essay notes.

Impact on Future Relationships

This chapter sets the stage for Marilla and Anne’s complex, mother-daughter-like bond. Marilla’s small acts of kindness show that she is capable of growth and love, even if she doesn’t admit it to herself. Use this before essay drafts to establish the foundation of their relationship.

Key Character Traits Revealed

Chapter 2 reveals Marilla’s strictness, her loyalty, and her hidden warmth. She is not a cruel woman, but she is trapped by her own rules and habits. Anne’s presence challenges her to step outside her comfort zone. List these three traits in your character analysis notebook.

Discussion Prep Tips

When preparing for class discussion, focus on specific moments rather than general claims. For example, alongside saying 'Marilla was nice,' talk about the small, specific action that showed her kindness. Practice using the sentence starters from the essay kit to frame your observations. Write two discussion questions using these starters right now.

How does Marilla feel about Anne in Chapter 2?

Marilla starts frustrated by Anne’s unexpected arrival and unruly behavior, then shows small, quiet signs of empathy, though she still plans to send Anne back.

Why is Marilla frustrated with Anne in Chapter 2?

Marilla is frustrated because Anne disrupts her strict routine and is not the boy she and Matthew planned to adopt.

Does Marilla like Anne in Chapter 2?

Marilla does not fully like Anne in Chapter 2, but she shows unacknowledged empathy that hints at future affection.

What small acts of kindness does Marilla show Anne in Chapter 2?

Marilla takes small, practical steps to care for Anne’s basic needs, even as she insists she will send her away. Specific moments are visible in the chapter’s interactions.

Editorial note: This page is independently written for educational support. Verify specifics with assigned class materials and the original text.

Continue in App

Simplify Your Literature Studies

Readi.AI is the go-to tool for high school and college students studying literature. It provides instant analysis, study plans, and essay help tailored to your assignments.

  • Quick answers for quiz and exam prep
  • Discussion question generators for class participation
  • AI-powered essay drafting and editing